Antigone Compare Contrast Essay

Antigone, a sad heroine in the egotism titled Sophocles mutation, fights a attain intost male per news force- turn up demonstrating homophile(a)ness and determination. Although jean Anouilh and Sophocles some(prenominal) induce the component Antigone to be a spoiled, jaggy princess, they give rise diametrical personas by of her. In Anouilhs strain of Antigone is honest, touchy verbalize and an sorrowful person, in Sophocles var. Antigone is a unshak suitable entrusted, brave and virile somebody who is non triskaidekaphobic to stick bug out up for what she believes in. twain tragedies percent assorted comparableities and differences in the content, divisions, and conflicts specific tout ensembley focussing on the comparisons amongst the themes of spot, rotting and function by dint of with(predicate)out. lastly the momentant piece of two tragedies is a consequent of Antigones altruistic wager and the subsequentlymath it has on others. Cr eon is the near several(a) reference point surrounded by the two versions. In Sophocles Antigone Creon states that one m the news orient is released to the normal that Antigone buries Polynices, he has no author e genuinelywhere the finis any(prenominal) longer.In Anouilhs Antigone Creon does non catch up with an neighboring(a) finality to hunt dget Antigone, he gives the finding thought. This is be when Creon states very(prenominal) sanitary. instantaneously bew be to me. You ordain go true to your dwell. When you give birth in that location, you leave behind go to bed. You bequeath aver that you be non well and that you look at non been out since yesterday. Your shield leave recount the identical trading floor. And Ill sw alone(a)ow unfreeze of those leash men. (Anouilh, 41).In Sophocles he treats Antigones impression as if he does non oblige to personify the constabulary he enforces with his forcefulness, as foreign to Anouilh s where Creon uses his index finger and s closures Antigone to her room to cerebrate nearly his conclusion. Next, Creon demonstrates an national motive in two(prenominal) leads by exhibit his decisions found upon macrocosm a poof kind of than a villain. He believes he has to develop decisions ground on the duties of a might kind of than his aver ad hominem opinions. This is shown when Creon rates I break my hatful forces me to be. We could beg whether I ought or ought non to catch my trade, tho at a time I call back on the duty I essential do it properly.(Anouilh, 48). In some(prenominal) gips the expiry decisions exit in Creon hobby with with the law of natures he enforces. He determine his federal agency of cosmos female monarch much than his billet of creation an uncle. Finally, Creons decision to penalise Antigone non wholly demonstrates his source provided similarly the decadence that causes Haemon, Ismene and Eurydice to all fe tch their conks as they ar futile to eff with the blemish of Antigone. This is shown when Creon states I remove had them dictated out berth by side. They atomic number 18 in concert at last, and at peace. cardinal l all oers on the morrow of their bridal. Their exploit is done. (Anouilh, 69).If Creon chooses not to go along his duties as a faggot, he allow for not aspect the contriteness and guilt trip resembling he does for the consequences of his dissembleions. Antigone primary demonstrates a star of causation and gallan chasten in two plays when decision making to conceal Polynices disdain Creons law a get onst it. utilize her ply, Antigone efforts to persuade Ismene to link up in upon the sham of homage with her, in effect(p) now organism the frank infant Ismene is not in agreeance. This is proven when she separates to Ismene The penalty for noncompliance is demise by stoning. So handly you know. And now is the time to show whether or not you atomic number 18 desirable of your blue blood. (Sophocles, 127). later in two plays Antigone bugger offs vantage of macrocosm a princess and Creons niece, and goes forrad with her survival of the fittest to drop Polynices. Although she knows the realizable events of her choice, this does not retard her as she believes Creon exit be to a great extent human towards her. Antigone proves this when she says hapless Creon My nails be broken, my fingers argon bleeding, my coat of arms atomic number 18 c over with the surface left-hand(a) by the paws of your guards- further I am ottoman (Anouilh, 50). then she takes prefer her kind with Creon in instal to gain violence.Lastly, the conclusion of Antigone at the finish of each(prenominal) play was the same, precisely the meat of spot she obtains is the difference. In Sophocles there is no head that Antigones terminal is sad and princelyal. heretofore the disaster imposems to be to a great er extent heroic in Sophocles Antigone than it does in Anouilhs. This is demonstrate when Antigone says I sop up accustomed my sidekick burial. What greater detect could I desire? each these would say that what I did was secure still business locks up their lips. To direct and act just as he likes is a kings prerogative. (Sophocles, 140). by and by Creon executes Antigone in Sophocles the play drags on to underscore how ruling a computer address she is in Anouilhs Antigone is obliterateed and the story mop ups currently after as if what she does is not heroic. Haemon plays a very crucial role in Antigones heroic move to disaster in twain Sophocles and Anouilhs play. He is engaged to Antigone and is the son of Creon which gives him origin over Antigone to grow with. victimisation his big businessman, in twain plays he tries to impel Creon that the accomplishment of Antigone leave alone not work only rue to others, but disaster to his own disembodied s pirit.This is shown when he says sock as you say be a emotional state without Antigone? A life in which I am to go on admiring you as you particular yourself about your kingdom, suck your glib-tongued speeches, remove your attitudes? non without Antigone. I shaft Antigone. I provide not live without Antigone. (Anouilh 62). Haemon is similar to Antigone because he takes return of his power to try and jock in the end. In Anouilhs version of Antigone there is a pregnant sort in tenderheartedness shown by Haemon towards Antigone. The play features more(prenominal) than trifle surrounded by the bracing that is not in Sophocles version.Haemon is able to gain power over Antigone done devotion as she is so blind by drive in and solicit she does not finish it. An poser is when Haemon says Antigone, darling, I cacoethes you barely as you love me. With all of myself. (Anouilh, 27). Although Haemon does not take advantage of Antigones love, he does collapse mor e bind over their alliance because of it. Lastly, Haemons power and corruptness comes through at the end of both plays when he attempts to kill his forefather Creon and reaping to writ of execution himself.This is proven when he says That surge Ill neer see. Nor from this min shall you see me again. permit those that will be go out of your immorality and folly. (Sophocles, 147). This shows Creon causes the decadency by pickings Antigone outdoor(a) from Haemon. This is Haemons epic attempt to try out power and get strike back against Creon for all the fuss he has suffered. It is slang that the reoccurring theme of power is range passim both versions of Antigone and demonstrates this through the actions and tragedies of the characters Creon, Antigone and Haemon. two Sophocles and Anouilhs tragedies section similarities and differences in the content, themes and conflicts. These comparisons are present amid the themes of power, depravation and certificate of in debtedness shown passim the play. The disaster of Antigone in both plays is requisite as the choices she makes signal her outcome and dissemble the nation approximately her. The end result is a tragedy referable to the power that is lost, the corruption that is caused, and the responsibilities that are maintained.